Author: admin

  • GEORG HEGEL & THE ETHICAL STATE

    French victory over Prussians at 1806 battle of Jena: Hegel in crowds cheering Napoléon Bonaparte = “Word Soul on horseback.” Editor of Bonapartist newspaper in Germany. Brother and brother-in-law killed during 1812 French invasion of Russia. Bonaparte’s liberal dictatorship = third way between Bourbon kings and Jacobin republic. 1789 French revolution = “the end of history”: social and political foundation of human freedom.

    18th century Enlightenment discredited Christian justification for absolute monarchy -> Hegel’s speculative philosophy discovers rational basis for state authority. World Spirit = the inevitable progress of the “idea of freedom” through repeated dialectical contradictions of global history: Asia -> Greece -> Rome -> Germany. 1807 Philosophy of the Spirit: the master-slave dialectic as the primordial struggle for recognition explains pre-1789 class society divided between aristocrats and labourers. 1517 Martin Luther’s 95 Theses = Protestant equality of believers -> 14/7/1789 Storming of the Bastille = Hegelian equality of citizens. Slaves have learnt to beat masters on the battlefield = end of history as feudal class antagonisms. Instability of post-1789 France: Liberalism = atomised individualism into social chaos -> Jacobinism = Absolute Liberty into Absolute Terror. Bonaparte’s 1799 coup d’état -> Napoleonic empire: meritocratic elite = “every soldier has a Marshal’s baton in his knapsack”; mixed form of government = Emperor, Senate, Tribunate & Conseil d’État; and European unity = Code Civil, common currency & single market. 1821 Philosophy of Right: military defeat of Bonaparte -> political victory of Bonapartism. Hegel’s obscure language = Freemasonry’s occult truths: king of Rome disguised as king of Prussia.

    Hegel’s political philosophy = negative freedoms of civil society -> substantive freedoms of the state. Modernity = master-slave dialectic superseded by bourgeois citizenship. Hegel admires liberal economics of Adam Smith and David Ricardo. Private property = externalisation of individual wills. Family = patriarchal contract between two individual wills. Law = universalisation of individual property ownership. Market competition between property owners = multiplication of needs -> one-sided development of bourgeois individuals. Civil society = dynamic and egoistic -> anarchy and collapse. Mass poverty -> violent revolution.

    Bonapartist state imposes political discipline upon capitalist competition. Three estates as intermediary institutions between ruler and ruled: notables, bourgeoisie and bureaucracy. Assembly of notables = hereditary or appointed landowners who serve the state and funded by land rent. Corporations of bourgeoisie = urban merchants, artisans and bankers who create both wealth and deprivation. State bureaucracy = meritocratic civil service outside and above civil society. Political supervision of market economy: law, defence, infrastructure, welfare and education. Patriotism = reconciliation of individual wills and collective interests through ethical concept of state. Hegel rejects social contract theory of Rousseau = levelling conformity of Jacobin republic. Hegel advocates mixed constitution with separation of powers between executive = bureaucracy and legislature = notables and corporations. Wealth moderated by wisdom.

    The people’s emperor: formless mass of egotistic individuals united by Great Man who personifies World Soul of historical progress. Monarchy is single mind above squabbling factions of notables and bourgeoisie. Long-term goals not short-term gains. Political and military leadership for national conflicts for global dominance. Hegel rejects Immanuel Kant’s belief that liberal republics = perpetual peace. Rationality of warfare = world-historical evolution from autonomous states into universal state. 14/7/1789 = realisation of freedom in one nation -> dissemination to all nations. Bonaparte’s downfall = hubris of ignoring intermediary institutions of Napoleonic empire. Mixed constitution enables selfish individuals of capitalist market to be patriotic citizens of ethical state. The end of world-history = “the real is rational” for everyone everywhere.

  • Utopian Dreaming: 50 years of Imagined Futures in California and at UCSC

    Dr. Richard Barbrook will be speaking about two decades of The Californian Ideology at 3:15pm on Saturday 7th November for the California Techno-pasts & Utopian Futures panel at the Utopian Dreaming: 50 years of Imagined Futures in California and at UCSC conference, UCSC, Santa Cruz, California.

  • THE CLASS OF THE NEW

    Building upon the analysis in Imaginary Futures, this 2006 OpenMute book explains the historical predecessors and later remixes of Daniel Bell’s concept of the knowledge class.

    Download the pdf version for free

  • INTRODUCTION TO BRAZILIAN EDITION

    The email came from the translators in Brazil: “We want you to write an introduction to the Portuguese version of Imaginary Futures – something special for the local readers.” What should I say? My immediate thought was that Suba, Marky and Patife were on the soundtrack during the all-night writing sessions which created this book. Their rhythms contributed to the construction of its sentences and the flow of its arguments. Maybe I should begin the introduction by explaining why these musicians were in the mix? It definitely was no accident. Thanks to my job at Westminster University, I’ve had the pleasure of teaching some very smart Brazilian students over the past decade. Through them and other contacts, I’ve made the long journey south three times to speak at conferences and festivals in Rio, São Paulo, Brasilia and Pipa. I’ve danced at a samba school, in hip nightclubs and under the stars on a beach. I’ve discussed the politics of the Workers’ Party, analysed the global justice movement and debated leftist theory long into the night. I’ve admired the creativity and dedication of Brazilian artists, hackers and activists. Despite the language barrier, I now have dear friends in this fascinating faraway country. Enthused by these visits, I returned the favour by helping in 2005 to organise an event in London where Gilberto Gil talked about the Brazilian Ministry of Culture’s innovative new media initiatives. But, you might ask, what have these reminiscences got to do with this book? Why talk about them in the introduction for the Portuguese translation of Imaginary Futures? It’s because I recall sitting outside the Telecentro cybercafe in Pipa in 2004 when I was asked the all-important question: “Has being in Brazil changed the way that you think about the Net?” My task in this introduction must be explaining why the answer is: “Yes!”

    Imaginary Futures is a book about the political and cultural power of technological prophecies. During the Cold War, the American and Russian empires competed not only to control space, but also to own time. Computers and the Net have long been much more than useful tools. For over half a century, they have also embodied utopian dreams in the service of imperial ambition. The nation that is pioneering the future in the present can claim leadership over the whole of humanity. When I began the research for this book in 2002, my focus was exclusively on the North. I was fascinated by how the imaginary futures of the Cold War still dominated the contemporary world long after the fall of the Berlin Wall. The American empire might have prevailed over its Russian rival, but its boosters remained trapped within an ideological framework devised for this geopolitical conflict. Not surprisingly, this book reflects the times in which it was written: the aftermath of the dotcom bubble and the moment of the US-led invasion of Iraq. Across Europe, political leaders, academic experts and media commentators were convinced that America – the land of cutting-edge computing and the Net – was our tomorrow today. Where the US president led, our countries must follow – even if it meant sending troops into foreign lands where they weren’t welcome. As one of the two million people who marched against this folly in London on 15th February 2003, I wrote this book as a howl of protest. By painstakingly explaining the history of the imaginary futures of artificial intelligence and the information society, I wanted to equip its readers with the knowledge to refute these anachronistic prophecies. The next time that someone told them that the post-industrial utopia was just around the corner, they could reply that this prediction was nothing more than recycled McLuhanism. The Cold War was over – and its made-in-America imaginary futures were too.

    As my questioner in Pipa was wondering, I didn’t need to visit Brazil or know anyone from the country to come to this conclusion. Few of the authors who fill the shelves of my study with their thoughts about computing and the Net are interested the impact of information technologies within the developing world. Like them, I could have said everything that I wanted to say in this book without making any mention of the majority of humanity. Computers and the Net are from the North, so why bother talking about the South? Fortunately, my Brazilian comrades have prevented me from succumbing to this lazy temptation. Their influence has added depth to the analysis of Imaginary Futures. First and foremost, I’ve realised how different the world looks from the South compared to the North. It’s not just the constellations in the sky that are upended, but also geopolitical memory. When I visited Brasilia in 2004, I saw with my own eyes the modernist edifices of a better society that was denied to their country. As the book emphasises, leading intellectuals of the American empire were cheerleaders of the 1964 military coup which overthrew the democratically elected government of João Goulart. The wonders of the US-style hi-tech future to come justified the horrors of the brutal dictatorship that was imposed on Brazil in this period. For those of us who live in Western Europe, it is always a shock to encounter the inequality and violence which resulted from this authoritarian path of development. Because our experience of American hegemony during the Cold War was relatively benign, we only truly understand the human costs of its imperial rule when we come to the South. The concluding chapters of Imaginary Futures reflect what I learnt from my Brazilian trips. When I was writing the book, I knew that the fiercest criticism of these utopian prophecies from the North was explaining how their advocates had tried to realise them in the South. Tellingly, I discovered that the American instigators of the 1964 coup in Brazil were also the architects of their nation’s disastrous invasion of Vietnam. With US-led forces occupying Iraq and Afghanistan, the parallels with the present had to be drawn. The desire to own time is intimately connected with the ambition to control space. When I looked at the world from the South, I could see how easily hi-tech dreams can turn into nightmares of barbarism and cruelty. Going to São Paulo was the precondition for understanding why – in Imaginary Futures – Saigon plays such a key role in the history of the global village.

    When I first visited Brazil in 2002, the importance of envisaging the world from the South when writing this book wasn’t immediately obvious. At the conference at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, our hosts entertained their foreign guests with the sad story of the local version of Californian hi-tech hype. Mesmerised by the late-1990s dotcom bubble, Fernando Henrique Cardoso’s administration had fantasised about Brazil making a great leap forward from underdevelopment to the information society without having to pass through Fordism. With the inhabitants of the nearby favelas lacking the basic amenities and welfare services which are taken for granted in Europe, we were appalled at how the imaginary futures of the North had given a modernist gloss to the perpetuation of exploitation in the South. When the supporters of the newly elected Lula government told us that reaching Fordism would be a major achievement for the urban poor of Brazil, we couldn’t disagree. Focusing the country’s economic policy on computers, the Net and mobile phones seemed grotesque when so many people lacked water, sewage, electricity, healthcare and education. We’d read our Marx – we knew that the South couldn’t avoid following the North’s slow and painful path to modernity.

    I then had a worrying thought. Ironically, our leftist sympathies for the inhabitants of the favelas might be disguising a dubious assumption of European superiority. With its huge gulf between rich and poor, travelling to Rio in the early-21st century does seem like going back in time to London in the late-19th century. It was certainly true that lots of tourists go to Brazil for a quick dose of exoticism and adventure before returning to their safe European homes. If our motivations for foreign travel were no purer, did this mean that the inhabitants of an underdeveloped country couldn’t tell us anything about computing and the Net that we didn’t know already? Here was another troubling conclusion. Cardoso had been a respected Marxist economist before he sacrificed principles for power. His perverse embrace of dotcom neo-liberalism might be founded upon a kernel of rationality: the South had faithfully to imitate the North in all its vices. With his ambition of jumping over Fordism to post-industrialism, maybe he was the true radical rather than the Lula government with its cautious programme of incremental reforms? Who wants to be Sweden when you could become Silicon Valley?

    Six years later, as the global financial system is wracked in crisis, it seems absurd that Brazil would want to transform itself into California. On the contrary, it’s now widely recognized that many of the elements of the new paradigm of modernity are more likely to be found in this supposedly underdeveloped country than in its advanced neighbour to the north. By the time that Mídia Tática Brasil invited me back for their conference in 2003, Gilberto Gil was already arguing – as a government minister – in favour of an open source vision of the Net. For him, funding community cybercafes and media hotspots complimented the provision of other essential amenities to the underprivileged. Most wonderfully, it was the copyright fetishists of the North who would have to imitate the South’s relaxed attitude to intellectual property not the other way around. The ownership of computers and access to broadband might be much lower in Brazil than Europe and America, but it was here that could be found the precursor of the participatory culture of the Net. Carnival not the market was the Minister of Culture’s model for the emerging information society. True to his roots in Tropicália, Gil is a true cosmopolitan. Imitation isn’t subservience – it’s inspiration and cooperation. Remixing, sampling and quoting are the tools of collective labour in the hi-tech-gift economy.

    In the conclusion of this book, I argue that we must invent new futures. Exorcising the Cold War ideologies of artificial intelligence and the global village is my contribution to mapping out a path through the multiple political, economic, social and environmental problems that now confront humanity. Crucially, as my interlocutor in Pipa guessed, you too have helped to create this text in a small way. Imaginary Futures would have been a different book in many subtle ways if I hadn’t visited Brazil and learnt from the people who I met there. The inhabitants of the North and South are in this venture of modernity together. So let’s continue our collaboration in the common endeavour of making a more equalitarian, sustainable and prosperous world. The drum ‘n’ bass is playing and this book is waiting to be read. Enjoy!

    Richard Barbrook,
    London,
    England,
    16th November 2008.

  • Stuart Hall: Stalinist in theory and Blairite in politics

    I suppose those who make their living out of teaching Cultural Studies have to mourn the demise of Stuart Hall. However, the airbrushing of Hall’s unpleasant politics in his obituaries cannot be allowed to pass without some attempt at correcting the historical record. Here are my thoughts which come from someone who – in more than one period of his life – was on the opposite side of the barricades to this high priest of philosophical confusion.

    Stuart Hall joined the CPGB (British Stalinist party) after the Russian army crushed the 1956 Hungarian revolution and remained a member through the 1968 suppression of the Prague Spring, the breaking of the 1970 Gdansk strikes, the 1979 invasion of Afghanistan, the 1981 Polish military coup and was still there when this shameful outfit finally dissolved itself in 1991 because the Soviet Union had imploded. During these three decades, he never took any public stand against the Russian occupation of Eastern Europe or the vicious repression of workers’ struggles by the Stalinist system. Silence = complicity.

    In the various fawning obituaries of Hall, he has been described as a great ‘Marxist’ thinker. Yet, if you read his publications, there is no evidence that he ever seriously studied Marx’s writings. The only references in them are to:-
    * The CPGB’s bowdlerised version of The German Ideology which carefully removed all of the passages where Marx and Engels gleefully mock the 1840s equivalents of Hall;
    * The chapter on commodity fetishism in Capital Volume 1 which Hall bizarrely mistook for a theory of ideology;
    * The most famous quotes from The Communist Manifesto; 18th Brumaire and The Civil War in France which every CPGB member was supposed to know.

    As far as I can make out, Hall never read the rest of Capital, Grundrisse, Theories of Surplus Value or any of Marx’s wonderful journalistic articles. I have taught undergraduate students who’ve read more of Marx’s writings than Hall ever did!

    Instead of Marx, Hall devoted himself to promoting Louis Althusser’s remix of Stalin’s socio-linguistics in the English-speaking world. During the late-1970s and early-1980s, his disciples were the most sectarian of any group on the English Left which – given our long history of Protestant sectarianism – is saying something. If you still need to understand why Hall’s obsession with Althusser was elitist and reactionary, please read Edward Thompson’s and Simon Clarke’s excellent articles which demolish the idiocies of this Stalinist philosophy.

    Since then, we’ve had two generations of academic leftists brought up on Hall who have wasted their energies on the spawn of Althusser: Foucault; Derrida; Deleuze & Guattari; Badiou; Zizek and so on. In this fifth year of the Great Recession, they have nothing sensible to say because they lack the basic theoretical knowledge to refute the propagandists of neo-liberalism. For, as Stalin and Hall argued, Marx’s critique of political economy was only for ‘textualists and Talmudists’ …

    In 1978, Hall and his BCCCS colleagues published Policing the Crisis which claimed that the rise of neo-liberalism was an entirely ideological offensive by the Tory party. Amazingly, this book never discussed Hayek, Mises, Friedman or any of the other bourgeois economists who Thatcher and her allies were loudly proclaiming as their gurus at the time. Then as now, refusing to study value theory was a big mistake. Even worse, Hall’s book splenetically denounced all English Situationists as ‘terrorists’ which – given how many of their ideas he’d stolen for the BCCCS’ work on youth subcultures – was most ungrateful. A year later, Dick Hebdige proved himself a diligent pupil of Hall when he published a book on the punk movement which never mentioned that its founders were English Situationists. Stalin would have been proud of both of them!

    In the early-1980s, Hall rose to prominence as the intellectual maestro of the Eurocommunist faction of the CPGB which controlled the party’s misnamed theoretical journal: Marxism Today. In issue after issue, he and his associates denounced the Labour Left’s struggles against the Thatcher monster as extremist and deranged. We just didn’t understand that the English proletariat was irredeemably racist, sexist and homophobic. It was Thatcher who knew how to appeal to these reactionary impulses – and our attempts to mobilise the working class in all of its diversity against her oppressive regime were doomed to failure. At first, Hall’s faction of the CPGB kept the Althusserian faith by analysing Tory rule solely as a ideological project. After a few years, even they eventually realised that neo-liberalism might have something to do with the despised discipline of political economy. However, instead of reading some value theory, Hall’s faction now proclaimed Thatcher’s regime as the future in the present. Neo-liberalism was the New Times to come which – most conveniently for them – meant that the Labour Left’s resistance to Tory hegemony was futile. Delighted that the local franchise of the Cold War enemy had switched sides in the class struggle, the right-wing press enthusiastically promoted the new party line of (anti-)Marxism Today. They knew that they could rely on the Althusserians to purge the ‘Trotskyist wreckers’ who threatened the bourgeoisie’s wealth and privileges.

    In the late-1980s, I was told by a member of Hall’s faction of the CPGB that they were very pleased that Thatcher had defeated the miners’ strike and crushed the local government Left because the Labour party would now be forced to adopt their centrist political programme. Within a decade, this prognosis was realised when Blair was elected prime minister on a manifesto which assured the bankers that New Labour had no intention of breaking with Thatcher’s neo-liberal settlement. In the early reforming years of this administration, Hall made not one word of complaint about its failure to repeal anti-trade union laws, its attacks on welfare claimants and various other dubious policies. However, when New Labour eventually got old and discredited, he suddenly reappeared as a critic of the neo-liberal government which his faction of the CPGB had helped into power! Of course, we should always welcome someone who recants their past errors. Yet, Hall was still incapable of providing any intelligent analysis of the failings of neo-liberalism because this would have required the one thing that he’d always refused to do: studying Marx’s critique of political economy.

    If there is one lesson to be learnt from this sad tale of political failure and theoretical chicanery, we must not make the same mistake as Hall and his disciples. Comrades – let us become Marxists who’ve read some Marx!

  • Californian Ideology Then & Now

    Dr. Richard Barbrook will be speaking about two decades of The Californian Ideology at 3.20pm on Wednesday 9th October for the Networked Art panel at RENEW 2013: the 5th International Conference on the Histories of Media Art, Science and Technology in Riga, Latvia.

  • Imaginary Futures at ITSC Cologne Conference

    Dr. Richard Barbrook will be the keynote speaker for the Media Evolution and Society session at the Internationales Film & Fernsehfestival at 2.00pm on Friday 5th October in Köln, Germany.

  • Imaginary Futures at Future Camp

    Dr. Richard Barbrook will be participating in the Dark Web/Deep Web/ Invisible Web panel of Future Camp at 9.30pm on 28th September 2012 at Kampnagel, Jarrestraße 20, 22303 Hamburg, Germany. Other speakers include Angela Richter, Andreas Leo Findeisen and Ote Reissmann.

  • Imaginary Futures at the Futurological Congress

    Dr Richard Barbrook will be talking about Imaginary Futures at the Futurological Congress in Lviv, Ukraine, on Saturday 27th November at 3.30pm.

    Location: Center for Urban History of East-Central Europe, Bohomoltsia 6, Lviv.

    Besides this presentation, Richard Barbrook will also be hosting a Class Wargames performance for the Futurological Congress with Stefan Lutschinger on Sunday 28th November at the Center for Urban History of East-Central Europewhich will feature a collective playing of Guy Debord’s The Game of War accompanied by a discussion of its importance to our understanding of Situationist theory and practice.

  • Imaginary Futures is published in Polish

    PrzyszÅ‚oÅ›ci Wyobrażone – the Polish translation by Jan Dzierzgowski of Imaginary Futures – has been published by Muza SA in their Spectrum series. For more information, check out the Muza website.

  • Imaginary Futures Author at Transmediale 10

    Dr Richard Barbrook will be appearing at Transmediale 10 to open its The Futurity Long Conversation – ‘a relay of one-to-one conversations, brings 21 leading artists, designers, theorists, journalists and media interventionists together to discuss, contextualise and explore the abstract and qualitative elements defining what we conceive of the future today’ – at 1.00pm on Friday 5th February in Haus der Kulturen der Welt, Berlin, Germany. For more information, check out the Transmediale website.

  • Editora Peirópolis Publishes Futuros Imaginários

    Editora Peirópolis from São Paulo, Brazil, have just published Futuros Imaginários – das máquinas pensantes à aldeia global – the Portuguese translation of Imaginary Futures. Richard Barbrook will be visiting the country over the next two weeks for a lecture tour to promote the book. His first appearance will be at the International Seminar “Information, Power, and Politics: new institutional and technological mediationsâ€? on 15th-17th April at the Auditorium of the CPRM – Research Company for Mineral Resources, Av. Pasteur, 404, 4th floor, Urca, Rio de Janeiro.

    Buy the book

    Download the pdf version

  • Imaginary Futures Author at Transmediale ’09

    Dr Richard Barbrook will speaking the Transmediale Festival ’09 in the session on ‘How Enthusiasts, Amateurs and Hobbyists Shape the (Music) World’ at 3.00pm on Tuesday 27th February at Kunstraum Kreuzberg Bethanien, Mariannenplatz 2. 10997 Berlin-Kreuzberg. For further details, see the Transmediale Festival website.